In Bobbie Ann Mason's "Shiloh", a trucker is terribly injured in a highway accident, resulting in the loss of his job (5) and a return to his home, his wife, and his marriage. This trucker, Leroy Moffitt, believes that his injury is a blessing in disguise, because he believes they must "start afresh" (9) now that he is pemanently home. His wife Norma Jean, however, is made more uncomfortable by his presence; at one point Leroy admits that oftentimes she is almost surprised to see him when she enters their house. Nonetheless, both characters share one trait: they are in the midst of a renaissance in their lives - but they are going in opposite directions with them. Separation is at the heart of all this change and tension.
Leroy and Norma Jean get married at the tender age of 18, due to the fact that Leroy impregnates her (26). Following the death of their son, Leroy becomes a trucker and goes on the road for the next 15 years, stopping only occasionally at his own house (16). Instead of confronting the emotions attached to the loss of their baby, Leroy and Norma Jean betray their immaturity by running away from the problem - or, in Leroy's case, driving away from it. As a result, they never really talk about their lost son, and this is one reason why the second-chance marriage fails. Although Leroy and Norma Jean were technically married during this 15-year period, it was really a separation, emotionally and physically, caused by the child Randy.
This long separation, coupled with the forced reunion of their marital union, shakes them both up. Leroy takes up a number of hobbies: hobbies that would be common for a 10-year-old boy, but hobbies that are depressingly pathetic for a 34-year-old man to be doing (6). Norma Jean, on the other hand, reinvigorates her life. She cannot stand to be around Leroy, perhaps because he reminds her of Randy (9), or perhaps because she is simple not used to being around someone - as she says at the conclusion of the story, she wants to be left alone (154). Nevertheless, Norma Jean partakes in a number of activities that will benefit her life. She begins lifting weights, jogging, and even enrolling in a course at a community college (86). She is already preparing herself for another separation with Leroy, but one that this time will be a conscious decision on her part.
Thus, the aformentioned renaissances are revealed: Leroy desires a rejuvenation of his marriage, and Norma Jean wants to begin a new life by ending her marriage. Shiloh serves as the scene for the climax that we knew was coming all along: Norma Jean finally voicing her wish for a divorce. Interestingly, Leroy is shocked by the statement, even though he knew "he [was] going to lose her" (94). And unfortunately for Leroy, the rebirth of his marriage ends in death, like the son he once had. For Norma Jean, her goal of separation succeeds as she speeds past Leroy when he is trying to catch up with her. However, her renaissance for a new life might also have ended in death, as Bobbie Ann Mason's ending is arguably ambiguous. Regardless of whether or not Norma Jean jumps in the end, the marriage of the Moffitts ends at the battlefield, where many men lost their lives, and where one trucker appears to lose his. (573)
Sunday, September 28, 2008
Sunday, September 21, 2008
The Effects of Jealousy in Raymond Carver's "Cathedral"
From the beginning of this short story, it is very clear that the main character dislikes his wife's blind friend. However, the reason for this dislike is not so clear, on the surface. The character attributes his dislike of the man to a dislike of the blind: "The blind moved slowly...never laughed...were led by seeing-eye dogs" (1). But these offensive comments are almost comical in their absurdity; after all, whoever heard of being prejudiced against the blind? The comments are so ridiculous that they practically invite the reader to find a deeper, more meaningful explanation for this man's disgust with his wife's blind friend. In reality, the simple answer to all of these repressed feelings of disapproval is nothing more than jealousy.
To begin with, the husband is jealous of his wife's former life - and, especially, her former lover. His quick dismissal of their relationship is evidenced in paragraph two: "She was in love with the guy, and he was in love with her, etc." The et cetera is particularly significant in that it represents the (apparent) disinterest the main character has in his wife's relationship with this "guy." The et cetera appears again in paragraph three: "...married her childhood, etc." From what we can interpret, this man's wife had a fine relationship with "her childhood" - that is until she divorced him, resulting from her loneliness from the life of an officer's wife. And throughout all this, she was maintaining a relationship with the blind man, and in the process, she became much closer to him than she was to anyone in her life.
And so we now come to the true cause of the jealousy: the blind man, the friend who helped the main character's wife through the most difficult period of her life. In this period, she attempted suicide, moved away from her husband, divorced, and then finally met the main character, her future spouse. Yet despite all these traumatic events, in spite of it all, the blind man managed to stand by her in spirit and on tape. It could even be argued that he was the reason she was still alive, since everyone needs some kind of emotional outlet. But the fact remains that the wife's relationship with Robert has proven to be the best relationship in her life. This is best illustrated when Robert visits, because the wife seems rather disappointed she can't be with Robert: "My wife...looked at me...[and] she didn't like what she saw" (30). Furthermore, the wife will not admit to Robert that marrying her husband was a good thing; at least, that's how our main character interprets it (46). Finally, the last indication of an inferior spousal relationship is when the narrator admits that "[his] wife and [he] hardly ever go to sleep at the same time" (85), a good sign of a dysfunctional relationship.
In total, the wife may have spent more time with Robert and the tapes than she has with her current husband - and the husband knows this. He knows that she is disappointed with him, that she has more love for Robert than she has for her own husband, and it is for this reason that the husband hates Robert - at first. He hates him for his emotional relationship with his wife. By the end of the story, however, he has developed a like for Robert, a like that results from personality rather than physicality. The husband is never prejudiced against blind people at all, really; this is why it is so easy for him to become friends with Robert. The narrator does not have a problem with a physical handicap. His problem is one of accepting the lack of emotion between him and his wife, and his other problem is letting go of possibly the worst vice: jealousy. (636)
To begin with, the husband is jealous of his wife's former life - and, especially, her former lover. His quick dismissal of their relationship is evidenced in paragraph two: "She was in love with the guy, and he was in love with her, etc." The et cetera is particularly significant in that it represents the (apparent) disinterest the main character has in his wife's relationship with this "guy." The et cetera appears again in paragraph three: "...married her childhood, etc." From what we can interpret, this man's wife had a fine relationship with "her childhood" - that is until she divorced him, resulting from her loneliness from the life of an officer's wife. And throughout all this, she was maintaining a relationship with the blind man, and in the process, she became much closer to him than she was to anyone in her life.
And so we now come to the true cause of the jealousy: the blind man, the friend who helped the main character's wife through the most difficult period of her life. In this period, she attempted suicide, moved away from her husband, divorced, and then finally met the main character, her future spouse. Yet despite all these traumatic events, in spite of it all, the blind man managed to stand by her in spirit and on tape. It could even be argued that he was the reason she was still alive, since everyone needs some kind of emotional outlet. But the fact remains that the wife's relationship with Robert has proven to be the best relationship in her life. This is best illustrated when Robert visits, because the wife seems rather disappointed she can't be with Robert: "My wife...looked at me...[and] she didn't like what she saw" (30). Furthermore, the wife will not admit to Robert that marrying her husband was a good thing; at least, that's how our main character interprets it (46). Finally, the last indication of an inferior spousal relationship is when the narrator admits that "[his] wife and [he] hardly ever go to sleep at the same time" (85), a good sign of a dysfunctional relationship.
In total, the wife may have spent more time with Robert and the tapes than she has with her current husband - and the husband knows this. He knows that she is disappointed with him, that she has more love for Robert than she has for her own husband, and it is for this reason that the husband hates Robert - at first. He hates him for his emotional relationship with his wife. By the end of the story, however, he has developed a like for Robert, a like that results from personality rather than physicality. The husband is never prejudiced against blind people at all, really; this is why it is so easy for him to become friends with Robert. The narrator does not have a problem with a physical handicap. His problem is one of accepting the lack of emotion between him and his wife, and his other problem is letting go of possibly the worst vice: jealousy. (636)
Tuesday, September 9, 2008
The Generation Gap in Alice Walker's Everyday Use
The main source of conflict in this short story is Dee, or “Wangero Leewanika Kemanjo” (25), and her equally new-age male companion. These two clash with the mother of Dee and her other daughter, Maggie, both of whom live in an old, cheap house, with “three rooms”, a “tin roof”, and “no real windows” (14). The style of this house is one source of the conflict, as it is “just like the one that burned” (14); that is to say, it is decrepit and shoddy. The “one that burned” was an apparent embarrassment to the person formerly known as Dee: when it burned, her mother was surprised she didn’t “dance around the ashes” (10), and Mama Johnson can’t believe it when Wangero takes pictures of her and Maggie “and the house” (23). However, this newfound appreciation expressed by Wangero for the timeworn is quickly identified as nothing more than a passing fad, a generational hobby that neither Mama Johnson nor Maggie can understand, but something that they can recognize as completely ersatz.
There are many indications throughout the story that these emotions expressed by Wangero are not genuine. For example, when she makes a big fuss about the old quilts, Mama Johnson tells us that just a few years prior, when Dee went to college, she thought the quilts were “old-fashioned” and “out of style” (67). Another instance of insincerity is when Wangero is taking all the pictures upon her arrival: she makes sure to capture the most ancient things, which is namely the house and Mama Johnson herself. Again, before Dee went away to college, she would bring very few people around to the house, as mentioned earlier. Finally, Wangero is false in her emotions toward her own family, which is worst of all. She puts on a loving, appreciative façade for “Hakim-a-barber” (42), when in reality she cares very little for her family, as she has always. At sixteen, Dee considered her mother and her sister as “dimwits” (11), and there is no reason now to believe she feels otherwise. Her true nature is revealed when, after being denied the quilts, she storms off in a huff to the car, where she tells Mama Johnson, “You just don’t understand” (79). She then puts on her sunglasses (82), perhaps to hide her disgust from her family. In essence, though Wangero claims to be a new person, she has all the emotions of the old Dee: namely, embarrassment for and disgust towards her backwards family.
And yet, despite these obvious feelings of resentment, Mama Johnson and Maggie do not seek, and perhaps do not wish to seek, to change anything about their lives. They are set in their ways, not caring how Wangero thinks about them; after she and Hakim-a-barber leave, the mother and her daughter go back doing what they had been doing before, what they have been doing all their lives: relaxing in their yard with a dip of snuff while the sun goes down (83). They are both, if not happy, content with their lives, unlike Wangero, who is in her heart ashamed of hers. Mama Johnson and her daughter go about the same rituals as “Big Dee” and "Grandma Dee” (75): sewing, cleaning, cooking, having a dip of snuff. And, in this sense, they understand their heritage more than Wangero ever will, no matter what she may think (81). Because Maggie would both appreciate and use the quilts, and understand and remember how they got their, they would mean so much more to her; Wangero, on the other hand, would “hang them” (72), which would destroy the very meaning of those quilts. They were made to be used, not admired; they were made to be worn-down and raggedy, not preserved. It is in this aspect that Wangero confirms just how little she “understands” her heritage – she admires these objects of her past (which include her family) almost as if shopping at an antiques store, whereas Mama Johnson and Maggie appreciate the objects for what they really are: reminders of the people they have loved. In this regard, Wangero, or Dee, will never understand what that truly means. (690)
There are many indications throughout the story that these emotions expressed by Wangero are not genuine. For example, when she makes a big fuss about the old quilts, Mama Johnson tells us that just a few years prior, when Dee went to college, she thought the quilts were “old-fashioned” and “out of style” (67). Another instance of insincerity is when Wangero is taking all the pictures upon her arrival: she makes sure to capture the most ancient things, which is namely the house and Mama Johnson herself. Again, before Dee went away to college, she would bring very few people around to the house, as mentioned earlier. Finally, Wangero is false in her emotions toward her own family, which is worst of all. She puts on a loving, appreciative façade for “Hakim-a-barber” (42), when in reality she cares very little for her family, as she has always. At sixteen, Dee considered her mother and her sister as “dimwits” (11), and there is no reason now to believe she feels otherwise. Her true nature is revealed when, after being denied the quilts, she storms off in a huff to the car, where she tells Mama Johnson, “You just don’t understand” (79). She then puts on her sunglasses (82), perhaps to hide her disgust from her family. In essence, though Wangero claims to be a new person, she has all the emotions of the old Dee: namely, embarrassment for and disgust towards her backwards family.
And yet, despite these obvious feelings of resentment, Mama Johnson and Maggie do not seek, and perhaps do not wish to seek, to change anything about their lives. They are set in their ways, not caring how Wangero thinks about them; after she and Hakim-a-barber leave, the mother and her daughter go back doing what they had been doing before, what they have been doing all their lives: relaxing in their yard with a dip of snuff while the sun goes down (83). They are both, if not happy, content with their lives, unlike Wangero, who is in her heart ashamed of hers. Mama Johnson and her daughter go about the same rituals as “Big Dee” and "Grandma Dee” (75): sewing, cleaning, cooking, having a dip of snuff. And, in this sense, they understand their heritage more than Wangero ever will, no matter what she may think (81). Because Maggie would both appreciate and use the quilts, and understand and remember how they got their, they would mean so much more to her; Wangero, on the other hand, would “hang them” (72), which would destroy the very meaning of those quilts. They were made to be used, not admired; they were made to be worn-down and raggedy, not preserved. It is in this aspect that Wangero confirms just how little she “understands” her heritage – she admires these objects of her past (which include her family) almost as if shopping at an antiques store, whereas Mama Johnson and Maggie appreciate the objects for what they really are: reminders of the people they have loved. In this regard, Wangero, or Dee, will never understand what that truly means. (690)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
